When the Law Bows to the Powerful: PNG's Justice System and the Politics of Impunity
by PAUL L. KEBAIJA On 16 June 2026, the District Court at Waigani cleared ousted Kandep MP Don Polye of all three fraud and corruption charges, ruling that the evidence brought against him was insufficient to proceed. Polye — once the first sitting politician ever arrested and charged by the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) — walked out a free man, his bail money refunded. Under the law, that outcome is entirely proper. A person is innocent until proven guilty, and a magistrate who finds the evidence wanting is doing exactly his job. Polye is entitled to his vindication. And yet the case lands like a familiar punchline. ICAC was sold to Papua New Guineans as the instrument that would finally hold the big men to account. Its very first prosecution of a politician the case meant to prove the new agency had teeth collapsed at the committal stage for want of evidence. Ordinary citizens are forgiven for asking a blunt question: if the state cannot assemble a case against t...